Skip to main content

JusticeFinder Tool

Total-Loss Comparison Calculator

Compare repair costs with an entered vehicle value using a percentage cutoff or a repair-plus-salvage formula. See the dollar difference and test different assumptions. This tool does not appraise your vehicle, determine a payout, or decide whether your insurer will declare a total loss.

Compare repair costs with an entered cutoff

Enter a positive ACV and repair estimate, then choose a model and confirm the applicable rule. The 75% starter value is an example. States marked under review do not supply a verified rule.

Total-Loss Comparison Calculator controls

Loading calculator controls…

The car's pre-loss market value.
The cost to fix the vehicle.
Verified states set the rule automatically; others stay manual.
Percentage threshold (TLT) or repairs + salvage ≥ ACV (TLF).
Enter your state's threshold, or pick a common preset.

Entered-value comparison

Below entered cutoff

Repairs: 50.0% of ACV. Entered cutoff: 75% ($13,500.00). $4,500.00 below that cutoff.

Repair cost vs entered cutoff

0%Cutoff 75% · compared 50.0%100%+

Disagree with the ACV?

With the same repair and salvage amounts, a lower ACV makes either entered cutoff easier to reach. This comparison does not calculate a payout. Check the insurer’s valuation against comparable vehicles, mileage, options and condition; ask how to correct errors or use any appraisal process available under your policy.

Educational comparison only. The entered rule is an assumption, not an insurer’s decision or a determination that the vehicle is safe to repair. State law, policy terms and damage details matter. Calculations run in your browser; input values are not saved.

How to use this tool

  1. Open the calculator. Scroll to the interactive tool section and review the starter inputs already filled in as educational examples.
  2. Enter documented numbers. Replace sample bills, wages, rates, fault share, or care costs with values you can support with records.
  3. Compare the live results. Read each result card and its formula notes separately. These educational calculations are not a settlement range or a prediction of what an insurer or court will pay.
  4. Save and keep documenting. Copy or print the estimate, open a linked spreadsheet if available, then pair the output with related guides before any insurer negotiation.

Read JusticeFinder elsewhere

Short legal explainers on TikTok, visual case briefs on Instagram, daily threads on Threads — same independent editorial.

JusticeFinder Guides

Recommended Guides for Claim Strategy

Pair this calculator with the free adjuster tactics playbook and the paid claim kit to keep documentation, valuation, and negotiation aligned.

Visit Legal Guides →

Two comparison methods

Use a confirmed rule or clearly label your figures as a scenario.

In the percentage model, an $18,000 ACV and a 75% assumption produce a $13,500 cutoff. A $9,000 repair estimate is $4,500 below it. At $13,500 in repairs, the cutoff is reached. The percentage is an input to the example, not a legal conclusion.

In the formula model, $9,000 in repairs plus $4,500 in salvage equals $13,500, which is $4,500 below an $18,000 ACV. Salvage does not affect the percentage model. Zero ACV produces an input message rather than a verdict or percentage.

Why vehicle value changes the comparison

Lower ACV makes either entered cutoff easier to reach.

Keep repairs at $9,000 and the percentage at 75%. Lowering ACV from $18,000 to $10,000 lowers the cutoff from $13,500 to $7,500, so the same repairs now exceed it by $1,500. Review the valuation inputs instead of changing ACV solely to obtain a preferred calculator result.

California's Department of Insurance explains ACV and policy appraisal provisions in its automobile claims guide. Use those sections as background, and confirm the rules that apply to your own policy and state. See the total-loss claims guide for related records and next steps.

Related Resources

Use these pages and documentation tools to validate the estimate, preserve evidence, and keep the claim file organized.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does this calculator decide whether my car is a total loss?

No. It compares the values and rule you enter. The insurer's decision depends on the applicable law, policy, damage and valuation. A result below the entered cutoff is not a finding that a vehicle is safe to repair.

What is actual cash value (ACV)?

The car's fair market value just before the loss — what a willing buyer would have paid for it in its pre-accident condition, accounting for age, mileage, and condition.

TLT vs TLF — what's the difference?

The percentage model compares repair cost with ACV multiplied by the entered percentage. The formula model compares repair cost plus salvage with ACV. Equality reaches the cutoff. The default 75% is an example, not a nationwide rule.

Can I challenge the insurer's ACV?

Ask for the valuation report and check the vehicle details and comparables. You can ask how to correct errors and whether your policy provides an appraisal process. A higher ACV makes the same repair costs a smaller share of value in this model; it does not guarantee a different claim decision.

Educational Use Disclaimer

Educational comparison only, not a legal, safety or insurance determination. Confirm the applicable rule with your insurer, policy and state insurance department. This calculator does not calculate taxes, fees, deductibles, loan payoff or a settlement payment.

Explore More JusticeFinder Tools

Related calculators in this claim stage. Browse the full library for every damages, coverage, and deadline tool.

View all tools

Continue Exploring

Move from calculator estimates into documentation, deeper guides, or the rest of the JusticeFinder tool library.

Continue Exploring

Keep moving through the claim process.

JusticeFinder is designed so every visit can turn into a concrete next step, whether that means opening a calculator, reading a guide, organizing records, or searching the library directly.

Read JusticeFinder elsewhere

TikTok, Instagram, and Threads — short-form legal explainers from the editorial team.